The Fly on rhe Wall

 

By Tony Hillerman

John Cotton is a political reporter for a newspaper in a large Midwestern city. He works out of the statehouse along with several other reporters from various other media outlets. 

It's election season and the governor is running for reelection. Roark seems like a competent and honest politician but he is facing a challenge within his party by Senator Clark, who has his eye on the governorship. Any scandal within state government would be a black eye for Roark and give Clark a chance to  become the nominee instead. 

One evening, while Cotton is finishing up work in the capitol press room, another reporter comes in and claims to be working on a really big story. The reporter, McDaniels, is drunk and tosses his steno pad carelessly down on his desk and leaves the press room. But McDaniels shortly ends up dead, of an apparent accident, tumbling over a railing and falling to his death.

Cotton is curious about the big story McDaniels was working on and finds the steno pad which had fallen down between the McDaniels' desk and the wall. Reading the man's cryptic notes, it appears McDaniels was investigating discrepancies in some highway projects. But it all seems to Cotton to be minor stuff and not something anyone would be willing to commit murder to cover up.

Then one night, at a poker game with friends, one man asks to borrow Cotton's car to run an errand. But the man is run off a bridge by a truck and the car plunges into the river, killing him. At first, Cotton assumes it was just an unfortunate accident. But then Cotton comes home soon after to find a fake bomb in his house and receives a threatening message telling him to stop investigating the highway story or be killed.

Fearing for his life, Cotton flies off to New Mexico, only to be tracked down by a hired killer while on a fishing trip. He manages to elude the killer and returns home, desperate to figure out what McDaniels was working on that someone is willing to commit two murders to keep hidden. 

This was a pretty good mystery story with a surprising twist at the end. It is also an interesting look at politics and corruption that is very relevant today. Towards the end of the story, Cotton explains why he believes political reporting is vital to the voting public:

"'You fault Gene Clark for having no political philosophy. Well, I've got one. I believe if you give them the facts the majority of the people are going to pull down the right lever on the voting machine. A lot of them are stupid. And a lot of them don't give a damn. And some of them have closed minds and won't believe anything they don't want to believe. But enough of them care so if you tell them what's going on they make the right decisions.'" 

 
Fifty years later, his description of the voting public still stands.

Duchess in Disguise

 

By Caroline Courtney

A Regency romance

Things are not good in the de Villiers household. First father died and now mother is dead and elder brother is now in charge and he has a gambling addiction and is deeply in debt plus the debts inherited from an improvident father and a foolish mother. If something doesn't happen, the three siblings will lose the family home. 

A letter arrives that just may save the day. The de Villiers name is ancient and honorable and a wealthy lord, a Duke, is interested in allying himself with the de Villiers family and wishes to wed Miss de Villiers, sight unseen. Problem is, Miss de Villiers is already in love with a worthy but not at all wealthy local man. So the youngest sibling, Clorinda, who is only seventeen, volunteers to marry the wealthy lord instead and save the family honor and the family home. 

So Clorinda is bundled off to London wearing her dead mother's old clothes and is immediately married to the Duke. He installs her at his mansion in the country and heads back to his hedonistic life in London. Naturally, Clorinda is not happy with this arrangement. So she hatches a plot to win the Duke's love. She will go to London to live with her sister, who is now also married, and with the very generous allowance the Duke set her up with and with a new hair style and fancy new clothes, and a false name, charm the Duke and make him fall in love with her. Complications ensue.

This was a good story, despite how silly it sounds. It is just a light and fluffy regency romance story, but sometimes a person just needs something light and fluffy. I enjoyed it. 

Dutch Uncle

 

By Marilyn Durham

A Western

Jake Hollander is a gambler with a past in law enforcement. He was settled in San Francisco but is now headed by stagecoach to El Paso, Texas. At one of the stops along the way, in various improble ways, he ends up in charge of two orphan Hispanic kids. Their mom was taking them to a boom town in New Mexico but she died on the journey. Jake is told to take the kids to the New Mexican town and deliver them to the address on an envelope found in the woman's luggage. 

When the three arrive, the address turns out to be a whore house and then the stagecoach leaves without Jake and another stage to El Paso isn't due for a month. Jake gets a temporary job as town sheriff, talked into it by an acquaintance from his days as a lawman and noted gun in Kansas. 

As Jake spends time in the tiny town, he renews his friendship with the Kansas acquaintance and his sister who are publishing the local newspaper. He also starts to build a relationship with the two kids, one of whom, the boy, Paco, has become very fond of Jake. In the process, Jake becomes embroiled in his old friends' problems and in trying to locate any family for the two orphans and in the various troubles plaguing the town. On top of all that, Jake's assaulted and robbed of his money belt containing his life savings. Things go from bad to worse when the orphans' father shows up and the only thing he cares about is the stolen money he left in the dead woman's possession.

I did enjoy this story very much. I did not like that the author kills off one of the orphans. I also thought that the strategies the author uses to tie Jake to the town and the two kids were rather contrived. And I found Jake's love interests in the story rather disappointing. But overall it was a good story, well worth reading.

There There

 

By Tommy Orange

Are group of people of Native ancestry come together for a big powwow in Oakland, California. They are all connected in various ways, some of which they are aware of and some of which they are not. 

Unfortunately some of them are not interested in the actual powwow. A drug dealer of Native and Hispanic origin owes dangerous people money and he and his associates have heard that the powwow will be giving away cash prizes. So they have a plan to attend the powwow and take the cash. 

The stories of the lives of the various people who come together for the powwow were interesting. These are people who have struggled and fought poverty and addiction and are working to overcome adversity and who are  heading to a hopeful outcome only for the reader to see it all brought to disaster because of a gang of hapless drug dealers. Some people find this sort of juxtaposition compelling and dramatic. I didn't. I frankly hated the violent and cruel ending. It spoiled the whole book for me.

The Way West

 

By A. B. Guthrie, Jr.

The story of a wagon train headed from Missouri to Oregon back in the 1840s.

Lije Evans was a farmer in Missouri with a loving wife and a teenage son. The three of them work hard and have a good life. But Lije is having second thoughts. He feels like he is just breaking even, not improving. So when folks start talking about immigrating to Oregon, which was currently part of the United Kingdom, Lije came to think maybe he should try his luck there. The word was that the land there was rich and productive and a man could get ahead if he was willing to put in the work. 

Lije talks his wife Becky into selling the farm and going west, even though Becky is happy in their little home on their Missouri farm. So off they went, sold the farm, loaded up their wagons, bought their provisions and headed to Independence, Missouri to form up a wagon train and brave the trials of the trails. They face the typical wagon train problems, accidents, deaths, natives, arguments, bison, heat, bugs, dust, river crossings, steep trails, lack of water, the usual. Actually, not too many people die in this story. One man dies of sickness, a woman has a miscarriage, a child dies of snakebite, a native gets shot by a settler. That's about it unless I am forgetting someone. 

This was a fairly good read. Not very exciting, and to someone who grew up in the 1950s, familiar territory. Lije is the main character with him moving up from traveling in the train to becoming the wagon train leader. Secondary characters are his son, his dog Rock and lastly his wife Becky. Rock gets more text than Becky does. Her main function is to tell Lije what a good guy he is. In fact, women in this story are mostly only there to cook and clean and take care of the kids and keep their menfolk happy. Their trials and tribulations are only touched on lightly. Not surprising for a book written in the 1940s.

Also not surprising for a book written in the 1940s is Guthrie's depictions of the natives encountered which he dismisses as lazy, dirty, heathen, ignorant, thieving savages. Near the end of the book, as the settlers are traveling by boat downriver, they pass a native cemetery. One of the settlers remarks about so many good indians, a reference to the old saying, the only good indian is a dead indian. 

If you have never read a story of the wagon trains headed west in America, this will probably be a very interesting story. But as a child of the 1950s, this story didn't tell me anything I wasn't already familiar with. I think the author touches too lightly on the suffering endured by the settlers and romanticizes it all a bit too much.  It did win the Pulitzer Prize for fiction in 1950. It is also one novel in a series that Guthrie wrote about settlers headed to Oregon, which I didn't know until I looked up the Wikipedia page about the book: Wikipedia.